The ultimate guide to MES vendors: selection, evaluation, and trends

The ultimate guide to MES vendors: selection, evaluation, and trends

Michael Möller
Michael Möller
12 mins
October 5, 2023

The digital transformation of manufacturing processes presents companies with ever new challenges. In the dynamic smart factory environment, choosing the right MES (Manufacturing Execution System) provider is becoming increasingly important. MES systems form the backbone of digital production and enable real-time process control. Their selection and evaluation therefore requires a high level of expertise and experience.

What factors should be considered when choosing an MES provider? Choosing the right MES provider is crucial for success in the digital transformation of manufacturing. A professional MES provider offers software solutions that adapt seamlessly to the company's specific requirements. This includes the implementation, training and maintenance of the MES system, as well as continuous support. Customers are looking for standardized solutions that can be adapted. However, major adjustments are mainly accepted by the customer only after the technical implementation has been launched. MES can be used to transform production processes in a company in the long term.

Introduction to MES (Manufacturing Execution System)

Before we look at the individual MES providers, it is first important to understand what Manufacturing Execution Systems They actually are and what function they fulfill.

What is MES?

In the vibrant world of modern manufacturing, MES looks like the central nervous system. It is a powerful technology that plays a crucial role by building a bridge between the manufacturing level and the corporate or management level. As Information and data hub The modular structure of manufacturing execution systems enables seamless communication and data flow of operating and machine data and thus ensures a higher level of efficiency, productivity and quality throughout the production chain. Think of MES as the brain that ensures stability and control amid the chaos of production lines, machines, materials, and workers.

To understand MES even better, you can think of it as a dynamic control center in which All threads converge. It collects, processes and analyses data in real time to enable well-founded decisions and optimize production processes. In essence, MES is a digital control center, which visualizes, monitors, controls and thus makes it possible to optimize the operation of a smart factory. It is the heart and soul of every smart factory, without which the vision of connected, automated and efficient manufacturing would only remain a dream.

Why is MES important in manufacturing?

It is now essential to understand the “why.” Why is an MES so crucial in the manufacturing industry? The answer lies in the increasing complexity of production processes and the growing need to consistently improve efficiency and quality.

In the modern manufacturing industry, an MES can be used as a type brain that coordinates a variety of tasks, all of which contribute to the efficiency of the overall process. It helps to ensure seamless communication between the various stages of the production process and provides a clear view of equipment performance. It enables companies to make informed decisions and improve production performance.

Increasing efficiency:
MES enables companies to track and analyze production data in real time. This allows them to react quickly to problems and reduce downtime.

Quality control:
By monitoring and controlling production processes, MES enables consistent product quality. Data is available online during the production process.

With MES, companies have access to detailed production and process data that helps them make well-founded decisions.

With an MES in the manufacturing industry, the Striving for perfection It will no longer be an unattainable dream, but a tangible reality.

The basic functions of an MES

Imagine a world in which every single activity in a manufacturing plant is monitored, analyzed, and optimized in real time. That is the world that a Manufacturing Execution System (MES) creates and maintains.

In its purest form, an MES consists of three basic functions. First of all, the Real time monitoring. With this function, the management team always has their finger on the pulse of production. Every machine, every line, every shift is continuously monitored so that problems can be identified and resolved early on. Second, there is the performance analysis. With MES, companies can analyze their processes and find out where improvements can be made. Finally, an MES provides quality management. The complete documentation of all production processes ensures quality and at the same time enables traceability.

These basic MES functions are the cornerstones that enable effective production control. They enable manufacturing companies to optimize their processes, improve product quality and increase efficiency. In today's fast-paced world of industrial manufacturing, an MES is no longer just a nice extra, but a indispensable tool.

The role of an MES provider

Standing at the heart of modern industry MES provider, which offer a wide range of responsibilities and services to ensure the seamless functioning of the Smart Factory. By implementing these same solutions, providers of software solutions can significantly increase production output, which leads to optimized efficiency and productivity. MES providers not only offer a range of services, but also technological innovations aimed at transforming and improving production processes.

Services and services from various manufacturers

Let's now look at the services and services that MES providers provide.

Die Responsibilities and services of MES providers are diverse and comprehensive. You are responsible for providing and maintaining the MES software that controls the manufacturing process. When the software is provided, it is adapted to the specific needs of the company, with the aim of increasing transparency, efficiency and productivity, thus sustainably reducing costs and improving quality.

However, the services offered by MES providers go beyond pure software provision. They also offer Training and advice to ensure that the company is able to exploit the full potential of MES software. They also ensure that the software is constantly updated and developed to keep pace with the rapidly changing requirements of the manufacturing industry.

How MES providers are improving production performance

Efficiency and productivity are the cornerstones of every production facility and MES providers play a decisive role in increasing them. They offer clever MES solutions, which are tailored to the specific requirements of production processes and thus help to increase throughput and reduce production costs. Your solutions enable companies to real-time data to record and analyze to monitor performance and identify opportunities for optimization

In addition, they help optimize quality assurance by enabling companies to have transparency about their production processes and to identify discrepancies immediately. Through their solutions, companies can make their production processes more efficient while ensuring that they meet the strictest industry standards. Their ability to help companies improve and optimize their production processes makes MES providers an indispensable partner in the world of Smart Factory.

Software solutions from different manufacturers

MES provider are the architects of a digital factory. Your software solutions are the core that connects the machines, systems and processes in a smart factory.

Imagine a huge, well-oiled machine, in which every single component works in perfect synchronization with the others. The software solutions from MES providers fulfill a similar function — they ensure smooth interaction of all production processes, from planning and control to quality assurance and performance measurement. Many MES systems are also able to evaluate machine data.

The main players are the various MES software systems. They are designed to take on a variety of tasks and to optimize the flow of information within the factory. Manufacturing Operations Management (MOM), Production Performance Management (PPM) and Quality Management Systems (QMS) are just a few of the software solutions that MES providers provide. Each of these solutions plays a critical role in improving production efficiency and performance by providing real-time data that can be used to make informed decisions.

Choosing the right MES provider

Before choosing the right MES provider Is hit, is the first Identify your specific MES needs in the foreground. It is important to create a clear picture of the desired features and functionalities in order to find the ideal partner. With detailed knowledge of these needs, you can rely on the Search for a suitable MES provider , where aspects such as expertise, trust, service quality, technical support and price play a decisive role. Therefore, identify exactly your specific MES needs.

that Identify these is the first and most important step towards digital transformation.

Start with a thorough analysis of your production processes. Map your workflows, report, identify bottlenecks and challenges, and ensure that you fully understand the fundamentals of your business model. It is important to know exactly what you expect from an MES system. Would you like to optimize your production planning? Or is it your goal to improve quality assurance? Perhaps you need a system to help you monitor compliance? All of these questions play a crucial role in identifying your specific MES needs.

Once you've identified your needs, you should document them in a clear and concise way. This list will become your guide when looking for the perfect MES provider. A good MES system must not only meet your current requirements, but should also be flexible enough to adapt to future changes.

What to look for when looking for an MES provider

After we have examined the important role that an MES provider plays in the manufacturing landscape, it is now time to start looking for the right partner. But What should you look for when looking for an MES provider?

Choosing the right MES provider is like finding the perfect ingredients for an excellent dish. You can't just rely on the first offer. The search requires care, time and a precise knowledge of what you need to do the end product to achieve.

It is always advisable to focus on providers who have a full range of services can offer to cover all aspects of MES. This includes the Implementation, training, maintenance, and continuous support. Another important aspect is the adaptability. A good MES provider should be able to provide solutions that can be tailored to the company's specific needs and processes, and not just standardized solutions. Lastly, but no less important, you should also consider the costs. It's important to find a provider that Value for money offers and has transparent pricing models.

Choosing the right MES vendor can be a challenge, but with the right preparation and considerations, you can find the ideal partner for digital transformation. Ideally, a partner who not only provides software, but also helps to increase efficiency and productivity and reduce operating costs.

Assessment of vendor experience and expertise

Now that we've explored the role of an MES vendor, it's time to start looking for the right provider. The assessment of provider experience and expertise is a decisive factor here.

Provider experience and expertise are two crucial elements that should not be underestimated when choosing an MES provider. Provider experience can be represented by years of work in the industry, the number of successful implementations, and by positive customer reviews. When evaluating expertise It is important to pay attention to the vendor's ability to deliver tailored solutions that are tailored to the specific needs of your smart factory.

It can be helpful References and case studies to get a clearer picture of the provider's performance. A vendor's ability to provide continuous support and maintenance, as well as their willingness to adapt to technological developments and market changes, are also important factors in evaluating their expertise.

Top MES providers on the market

Let's start with a brief but comprehensive presentation of various leading MES provider, which currently dominate the market.

Brief presentation of various leading MES providers

These companies are not only known for their high-quality solutions, but also stand out for their innovative strength and industry knowledge.

  • Rockwell Automation: Rockwell Automation is another leading provider of MES solutions. The company offers a range of FactoryTalk offers solutions designed to improve the efficiency and productivity of manufacturing companies.
  • FactoryTalk ProductionCentre: This solution is designed to optimize production processes and increase efficiency. Among other things, it offers functions to optimize production planning, quality control and energy management.

  • FactoryTalk InnovationSuite: This solution provides advanced analytics and reporting capabilities that enable companies to optimize their production processes and make informed decisions.
  • PinPoint: The company offers an MES solution that features a wide range of functions and can be used in individual systems as well as in global corporate structures. As a critical application, it integrates seamlessly with your automation and ERP systems.
  • PinPoint v5: With pinPoint V5, repeatable processes can be configured and implemented across the factory. The software has a comprehensive error prevention system that ranges from simple checklists to complex functional test devices and allows full product approval only after tasks have been completed.

lookout: It is important the offer to check carefullyto find the best solution for individual needs.

The innovative MES solution from gbo datacomp

Alternatively, gbo datacomp offers BiSoftMES a powerful alternative to Rockwell, Industrie Informatik and Co.

Transform your company into a powerful Industry 4.0 unit — with BiSoftMES. Your company benefits from an integrated system solution that includes all relevant operating and machine data seamlessly integrated. With biSoftMES, you are taking an important step towards a smart factory and thus effortlessly meeting the requirements of the modern production landscape.

Every detail of your production, from maintenance to quality to Personnel and management processes, is recorded in real time and presented clearly. The solution provides an up-to-date all-round view of production and seamlessly maps the resources involved and overarching processes.

Industry-specific default settings and customer-specific configurations ensure that BiSoftMES responds to all company-specific requirements. It integrates easily into your existing IT landscape and forms the bridge between shop floor and management level, such as your ERP system.

The modular structure of BiSoftMES ensures flexible scalability. Depending on your needs, you can connect additional locations, nationally and internationally, at any time. State-of-the-art interfaces to machines, systems, ERP and HR tools ensure a seamless data flow.

With the visualization options of the integrated dashboard and web evaluation generator, you can react flexibly to production changes — even from the home office.

Here are your benefits at a glance: effective, transparent manufacturing, significantly higher productivity, improved process quality, reduced operating and personnel costs, minimized set-up times and reduced lead times.

tip: Feel free to have a look at our website. There you will find all important information about BiSoftMes and other suitable software solutions for your company.

Comparing features and services from different providers

What about the different features of other providers? We'll take a closer look at this below.

When comparing the features and services of different providers, weigh Production management, quality management, material and warehouse management, and real-time performance monitoring difficult. For example Lifts Rockwell Automation due to its robust MES solution, which is specifically tailored to the needs of the automotive, food and beverage industries. This solution offers extensive functions for production management, quality management, and material and warehouse management.

It's important to recognize the unique benefits and strengths of each vendor in order to make an informed decision. Choosing the right MES provider is like choosing the right tool — it always depends on the specific requirements and goals.

MES provider for specific industries

After examining the points for choosing the right MES provider beforehand, it is a good idea to take a look at the specific providers for specific industries. It is important to understand that Not all MES solutions can be used universally and some providers specialize in specific industries.

They deserve a look here Infor LN and Rockwell Automation, which focus primarily on the automotive industry. With their special solutions, they enable a seamless integration of production processes, quality assurance and supply chain management. The fully integrated systems provide a comprehensive overview of production and ensure efficient resource planning.

Case studies — success stories with MES providers

Partnerships between companies and MES providers have led to complex manufacturing challenges surmounted and lean, efficient production was established. By presenting case studies that provide a detailed cost-benefit analysis of MES, the true meaning of Smart Factory Highlighted again.

How companies have benefited from working with MES providers

How do companies actually benefit from these partnerships? To answer this question, it is worthwhile to take a closer look at success stories based on cooperation with MES providers.

In the world of Smart Factory MES providers are proving to be indispensable partners for companies that want to optimize their manufacturing processes and make them more efficient. By implementing MES solutions can companies gain a competitive advantage in Industry 4.0.

Overcoming manufacturing challenges with MES solutions

In today's fast-paced industrial world, it is essential to produce efficiently and seamlessly. Here come the MES solutions into the game, which were developed precisely for these challenges.

An impressive example is the implementation of an MES solution at an automotive manufacturer. Previously plagued by countless manufacturing problems such as inefficient processes, high machine downtimes and a lack of transparency, the company has experienced a complete transformation. The MES solution made it possible to collect and analyze real-time data, which led to a drastic improvement in production planning and production control. This led to improved efficiency, reduced downtime and increased transparency throughout production.

The possible applications of MES solutions are almost limitless and range from production planning, quality control to machine maintenance. They enable companies to optimize their manufacturing processes and thus achieve significant cost savings and productivity gains. With the right MES solution, companies can successfully overcome manufacturing challenges and move on to a more efficient and productive one Smart Factory level.

Cost benefit analysis of MES

Careful and thorough implementation of Cost-benefit analysis can give companies a clear idea of what to expect when they invest in MES technology.

The cost-benefit analysis of MES is a complex process that not only takes into account the direct costs of software and hardware, but also includes indirect costs such as training, integration and ongoing maintenance. On the other hand, using MES offers a variety of benefits, which often outweigh these costs. efficiency gains are one such advantage. With MES, operating processes can be optimized, waste reduced and thus costs reduced. At the same time, product quality can be improved.

Another advantage is the Ability to make informed decisions to meet. The comprehensive analysis and reporting functions of an MES provide companies with clear insights into their manufacturing processes and can make well-founded decisions that can lead to further cost savings and efficiency gains. Despite the costs associated with implementing an MES, the cost-benefit analysis shows that the long-term benefits often outweigh the initial investments.

The future of leading manufacturers of MES solutions

Due to constantly changing requirements in industry, there are always new trends in MES technology and smart factories. But what exactly do these trends look like and what characterizes them?

Current trends in MES technology

The world of MES technology is a dynamic place. artificial intelligence and machine learning are on the rise and are beginning to shape the face of MES technology. With the integration of these advanced technologies, MES will be able to better predict production processes, optimize operations and ultimately increase factory intelligence.

There is also the trend of digital twins. This is a virtual replica of a physical object or system that interacts with the original in real time. In the MES world, digital twins enable more precise monitoring, analysis and optimization of production processes. They are at the heart of Smart Factory, which contributes to more efficient and productive manufacturing through precise and timely insights into production processes.

In addition, there is the growing importance of big data. The ability to collect and analyze huge amounts of production data provides MES systems with an invaluable resource. With big data, MES systems can identify patterns and trends that might otherwise have been overlooked and use these insights to improve production performance and reduce operating costs.

These current trends in MES technology are just the beginning of futuristic manufacturing. They're not just changing the way like We produce, but also the way we do about production think.

How MES providers are driving innovation and adapting

Such MES vendor success stories, as described in previous sections, take us seamlessly into the future of MES technology and how these vendors are innovating and adapting.

In the dynamic landscape of Smart Factory MES providers play a decisive role in shaping the future. They are constantly striving to develop innovative solutions that meet the ever-changing requirements of industry. An important strategy for this adaptability is the Integration of new technologies. Whether it's artificial intelligence, the Internet of Things, or machine learning, MES providers integrate these advanced technologies into their systems to increase the efficiency, productivity, and profitability of production processes.

They also manage to stay one step ahead by taking proactive measures to anticipate emerging trends in the industry. They invest massively in research and development to continuously improve their products and services and to ensure that they best possible solutions can offer that meet and even exceed the requirements of their customers. In this constantly changing world, MES providers are therefore not only providers of technology solutions, but also driving forces of innovation.

Cloud-based MES solutions

Now let's take a look at what's in store for the MES market. A key component of this future is Cloud-based MES solution.

In the world of smart factories, where efficiency and speed are essential, one technological achievement is becoming increasingly important — the Cloud-based MES solution. This technology gives companies a new dimension of flexibility and scalability. Gone are the days when you were forced to buy expensive hardware and install complex software. Today, cloud-based MES solutions provide access to real-time production data wherever and whenever it's needed.

These solutions not only improve operational efficiency but also reduce costs. Maintenance and updates are carried out by vendors, minimizing the need for in-house IT staff. They also create seamless scalability by allowing additional resources to be added as demand increases. This is how she Cloud-based MES solution to an important link in smart factories.

Conclusions and next steps

Now it is time to Preparation of an action plan to tackle, a structured approach that translates the improvement potential identified in the Smart Factory context into concrete measures. In this process, the Prioritize improvements a key role, it takes us specifically to the areas that have the greatest influence on the performance and efficiency of our production processes.

Summary of results

A careful look at the knowledge gained reveals a landscape created by dynamism and innovation is embossed. The data points paint a picture of MES providers who are striving to keep pace with the ever-changing requirements of smart factories. A strong focus is on the integration of Industry 4.0 componentsto increase efficiency and productivity. At the same time, there is a tendency to develop solutions that address the specific needs and challenges of manufacturing companies. This reflects the recognition that not all smart factories are the same and that an individual approach is needed to optimize performance.

Overall, the picture that emerges from the summary of the results is one of adaptability and future viability. It is proof that MES providers are not only responding to current trends, but are also proactively working to shape the future of manufacturing.

Preparation of an action plan

In the constantly changing landscape of smart factories, the need to plan strategically and sustainably is clearly evident. To achieve this goal, the Preparation of an action plan essential.

The correct design of an action plan starts with the precise definition of the goals and the identification of the required resources. In the world of Smart Factories Is it important to identify technologies and processes that are a Improving performance enable. The implementation of MES systems can make a significant contribution here. They not only allow data to be collected and evaluated, but also to prioritize improvements and plan targeted measures.

When preparing the action plan, it should be borne in mind that the introduction of new technologies entails not only technical challenges but also organizational changes. It is therefore crucial to prepare employees for these changes and to involve them in the change process. This is the only way to successfully implement the action plan and reap the benefits of Smart Factory be fully used.

Prioritize improvements

In view of the previously discussed future development of MES and their providers, the Prioritize improvements be examined intensively in the Smart Factory.

The digital landscape of smart factories is complex and constantly changing. It is therefore essential to systematically prioritize improvements to ensure that strategic goals are achieved. A tangible example would be the introduction of Predictive maintenance -Systems that monitor the state of machines in Monitor in real time and thus be able to prevent unexpected downtime and production losses. This technology could come first as it significantly improves both efficiency and cost optimization.

Another suggestion for improvement could be the implementation of artificial intelligence (KI) and machine learning (ML) be in production. These technologies can help identify errors at an early stage and help to improve quality assurance. However, the prioritization of such measures should always be based on a thorough assessment of current operating parameters and expected returns. It is therefore important to have a clear action plan based on solid data and analysis to set the right priorities.


Die Smart Factory From tomorrow, that needs correct MES system that not only optimizes production processes but also promotes innovation. A suitable MES provider Selecting is a critical step during digital transformation.

The future lies in continuous improvement and adaptation. With the right choice and implementation of an MES, companies can increase their efficiency while responding to changing market requirements. The ultimate guide This is a valuable tool for MES providers.

Kostenloses Whitepaper holen:
10 Gründe für MES in der Produktion

Optimierungen für die Produktion

Automatisierung & Flexibilität

Jetzt Whitepaper downloaden
Kostenlose Analyse holen:
Wir überprüfen Ihre Produktion

Fundierte Analyse mit Auswertung

Handlungsempfehlung & Beratung

MES Beratung vereinbaren
 100%  kostenfreier Security Check

Jetzt kostenfrei anmelden und wir überprüfen Ihr Sicherheitskonzept.

Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.